Defining Indigenous

At least 350 million people worldwide are considered to be indigenous, making up five percent of the world’s population. Indigenous people live in more than 70 countries and occupy 20 percent of the Earth’s land mass. Indigenous peoples’ traditional and non-traditional lifestyles and occupations include hunter-gatherer, nomadic pastoralist, farmer, fisherman, trader and merchant, to migrant laborer, scientist, teacher and urban professional.

The very term indigenous peoples is confusing because most people in the world are “indigenous” to their countries in the sense of having been born in them, being descended from people who were born in them. Indigenous peoples are clearly native to their countries in this sense as well, but they also make another claim: they were there first and are still there, and so they have rights to their lands. This criterion discriminates clearly enough between, for example, Native Americans and all those who came to the Americas after Columbus’ invasion. It also works well in other parts of the world that have been colonized from overseas. There is no problem in distinguishing the Aborigines of Australia or the Maoris of New Zealand as “indigenous” in contrast to the settlers who came later to those lands. These distinctions are not so easy to draw in Europe, Asia, or Africa. In those continents peoples have eddied this way and that, often for thousands of years, leaving in place a mosaic of different peoples who dispute the land and claim to prior occupancy of it. There are therefore additional criteria that must be used to define indigenous peoples for the purposes of any general discussion.

Indigenous peoples claim their lands because they were there first or have occupied them since time immemorial. They are also groups that have been conquered by peoples racially, ethnically or culturally different from themselves. They have thus been subordinated by or incorporated in alien states which treat them as outsiders and, usually, as inferiors. Isolated or marginal groups that have not yet been conquered by a state are also considered indigenous, because it is only a matter of time before they are subordinated. Indigenous peoples maintain their own languages, which normally differ from those spoken by the mainstream populations, and their own cultures, which invariably differ from the mainstream. They are conscious of their separate identities and normally struggle to retain these. The salient characteristic of indigenous peoples, then, is that they are marginal to or dominated by the states that claim jurisdiction over them.

Since they had not developed their own states and are not integral to the states that now actually or potentially rule over them, indigenous peoples are often referred to as “tribal.” The phrase tribal peoples is unfortunately imprecise. Nowadays it is used as a kind of shorthand to refer to small-scale, pre-industrial societies that live in comparative isolation and manage their affairs without any centralized authority such as the state. The worldwide tendency is for such peoples sooner or later to be conquered by states. Since the states then consider them aliens and inferiors, indigenous or tribal peoples are among the world’s most underprivileged minorities, facing the constant threat of genocide or ethnocide.

Maybury-Lewis, David. Indigenous Peoples, Ethnic Groups, and the State: as part of The Cultural Survival Studies in Ethnicity and Change. Allyn & Bacon: Boston, 1997, pp7-8.

CSQ Issue:

CSQ Disclaimer

Our website houses close to five decades of content and publishing. Any content older than 10 years is archival and Cultural Survival does not necessarily agree with the content and word choice today.